Mac Digital Jukebox: Importing Audio from Your CDs

- 2006.04.11

Back to business with our audio jukebox project. This week we'll examine the applications that allow us to get music onto our Macs. While there are more applications than the ones I'm covering today, not all are still available for download. If you happen to have a copy of SoundJam, MacAmp, or other long abandoned encoder, please feel free to use them if preferred.

Most people will want to bring digital music onto their Macs in one of two sources - ripping from CD or downloading from the Internet. Ripping from CD requires you to choose the quality of audio desired for the encoding process.

Lossless Encoding

At the top end are the lossless codecs that create big files while allowing for full CD quality audio. AIFF and WAV are the most common formats and simply represent a direct copy of a CD's data to your Mac.

There is not much difference between WAV and AIFF, and for all intents and purposes they are interchangeable. Macs tend to recognize the audio data as an AIFF file and Windows sees the same data as WAV. Technically, AIFF and WAV are not lossless compression schemes, as they don't actually compress the audio data. These formats do represent a lossless copy of the original file, and I desired a simple way of grouping the different audio formats.

Other popular lossless formats are Apple Lossless, WMA Lossless, and the open source FLAC (my favorite). Unfortunately, as far as I can tell, none are available on the classic Mac OS.

Again, while AIFF and WAV are lossless codecs in the sense no quality is loss from encoding, these two formats don't give any advantage in file size. FLAC, Apple Lossless, and WMA Lossless all allow for some compression, but retain full quality. Typically, file size is reduced by half with these true lossless codecs.

Lossy Encoding

On the opposite end of the encoding spectrum are the lossy codecs. The lossy formats applicable to this article, Ogg Vorbis and MP3, are characterized by greatly reduced file sizes and a corresponding loss in quality. These lossy codecs are measured primarily by their bit rate (kbps). The lower the bit rate, the smaller the file size, and the lower the audio quality.

Another technique for encoding is to select variable bit rate (VBR) encoding. By choosing VBR, the encoder is able to select a bit rate that varies on the fly depending on the quality needed by each segment of the audio track. The listed bit rate is an average of the track's continuously variable rate. While a song may be listed as 256kbps, any single passage of the song may be rated much lower or higher.

Overall VBR seems to be a welcome refinement of the lossy MP3 and Ogg Vorbis formats. There are further refinements available such as choosing between mono or stereo. Typically music will be encoded in stereo and spoken word sessions (such as a podcasts) can get away with a mono encoding.

Decisions

The most applicable encoding will depend on the specific goals of your project. The most important concern is typically storage capacity. If you have a Mac with a large hard drive, either internal or external, you can use the higher quality encoding.

Depending on the size of your CD collection and available storage capacity, one goal could be to make exact duplicates of an entire CD collection. Simply import the audio from the CDs as AIFF.

AIFF files can be played back on a wide range of computers and should be compatible with 68k Macs as well as PPC Macs. AIFF encoding is a very straight forward process. Simply select the AIFF encoder in your application of choice and begin. After all, an AIFF is simply a full copy - in both size and quality - of the audio from the CD.

If disk space is limited or particular listening needs entail cheap earbuds or computer speakers, lossy formats may be preferred. My rule of thumb is 128kbps VBR MP3 or Ogg Vorbis is the minimum acceptable. 128kbps constant bit rate is okay. Preferably I get much closer to 256kbps VBR MP3 and Ogg Vorbis.

How does one get music from a CD onto a Mac? Quite simple really. Start by firing up your designated Mac jukebox, place a CD in its optical drive, and select one of the following applications. Directions and options will differ depending on which application is chosen.

Audion 3.0.2

Audion 3.0.2 is the most flexible and robust of the currently available choices. Encoding CDs can be accomplished with the included MP3, MP3 LAME (despite the name, LAME is a great encoder), mp3Pro, and AIFF encoders. While Ogg Vorbis encoding support is missing, there is support for Ogg Vorbis playback.

I'm not sure which MP3 encoder is best in a technical sense, but I tend to use the LAME encoder.

The mp3Pro encoder deserves a quick note. In theory, mp3Pro will give you twice the quality of MP3 at the same bit rate. While the only application to take advantage of the format under the classic Mac OS is Audion 3, mp3Pro encoded tracks are compatible with other players. Under non-Audion 3 players, mp3Pro encoded files will play back as a normal MP3 without the increased sound quality available from mp3Pro. Unfortunately, mp3Pro never really caught on as a format, so I tend to stick with normally encoded MP3s.

When you use Audion 3 to encode (or rip) your CDs, I suggest connecting to the CDDB in order to automate the process of labeling artist, track name, album name, and genre. The CDDB is a repository for all the audio CDs people have previously labeled and uploaded the database.

Sometimes there are multiple entries into the CDDB for the same album. The Audion preferences can be set to automatically select the first choice or to present a list of choices. While the CDDB sometimes contains mistakes, I find the occasional manual nip and tuck of the results is a small price to pay for the time saved by CDDB doing most of the work. When importing your encoded music, Audion can create Artist folders and Album sub folders within designated output folder.

Automation

Audion's tricks for streamlining the process of importing music from audio CDs is only beginning. While a tad buggy for me, I found the ability to do batch importing handy. If you have a fair share of CDs to import, having to insert each CD and then manually selecting import can be a little tedious.

Once an encoding scheme has been selected, the batch process will prompt you to insert the first CD, and once the CD is finished encoding, Audion will automatically prompt you for a second CD by ejecting the first disc. Upon inserting the second CD, the process automatically begins again, until this CD has been encoded and is subsequently ejected.

This process will continue for as many CDs as you need to encode. The only real drawback to the batch encoding process is that every track from the CD will be encoded. If not all audio tracks are desired from a groups of CDs, then the batch process may be less of a time saver.

Labeling ID3 information continues to be very easy, even after encoding. Indeed Audion allows the ability to select multiple tracks when editing, which makes listing artist, genre, and album details much less tedious. If you like to tweak the actual audio file, Audion even has an MP3 editor with a few included effects.

iTunes 2.0.4

iTunes 2.0.4 is very similar to Audion 3.0.2, but it has far fewer features. Unfortunately, the choice of encoders is limited to two, MP3 (no LAME encoder option) and AIFF. The CDDB identification process works equally well, and creating artist/album folders is just as automated. iTunes 2.0.4 does not have a nifty batch encoding option, manually editing ID3 tags is not as slick, and it certainly lacks the options for customizing MP3s.

iTunes 2.0.4 is not a bad application, just limited in comparison to Audion 3.0.2.

Ogg Drop

Ogg Drop is the only currently available application for the classic Mac OS that encodes Ogg Vorbis tracks. It's a very basic application.

Once the encoding scheme is chosen, Ogg Drop will grind to a halt if an attempt is made to directly access a CD. It's better to use Audion or iTunes to identify the CD and then import as AIFF. Once you have an AIFF file, simply drag and drop onto the Ogg Drop Encode List window.

Adjusting ID3 tags is simple with the included ID3 tag editor. There are managed bit rate options, but the developer suggests to use the VBR option. Everything works well, if a tad slower than encoding MP3s.

Next time we'll explore the methods for discovering and downloading music online. I will examine the applications needed, the websites to visit, and deviate a bit by discussing the ramifications of DRM and a possible future solution to the non-interoperable DRM from separate digital music vendors. (No, I'm not specifically referencing the proposed French law or the obvious decision to not purchase DRM infected music.)

• Link: Free MP3 and Ogg Vorbis Software for Old Macs and the Classic Mac OS
• Link: MpegDec: Play MP3s and Streaming Audio on 680x0 and Old PowerPC Macs
• Link: FLAC
• Link: Apple Lossless, Wikipedia
• Link: Audion
• Link: iTunes 2.0.4
• Link: Ogg Drop